Perspective detail: The Baby Boomers, the Budget and Social Security

Perspective 3: Make Economic Security in Retirement a Personal Responsibility Rather than a Social Program

We need a dramatic re-thinking of Social Security. Current retirees would still get benefits, but for the future we need a system of mandatory personal savings accounts, which make individuals responsible for their own financial security in retirement. Mandatory personal savings accounts would either wholly or partly replace the current system, putting responsibility for retirement security where it should be, on each of us individually.

True, some people will make out better than others under this plan, because some people are better investors than others. .But if they do their homework and invest prudently, they ought to be able to retire in an acceptable fashion, allowing for the removal of this government program, which is going to be harder and harder to pay for as more and more baby boomers retire.


Therefore, we should:

  • Create mandatory savings accounts for every working American, similar to the 401(k) plans many employers offer now and funded with a portion of Social Security taxes
  • Allow individuals to decide how to invest their Social Security taxes, possibly through an approved list of mutual funds

Pros and Cons for this Perspective
Discuss this choicework